I needed a new laptop so I've decided to check whether I could find one that could fully replace my power-hungry desktop and at the same time get decent mobility. My desktop is a high-spec gaming rig with three full-hd screens dual booting Linux and Windows. Can you pack hardware and battery powerful enough to match that into a small pizza box?
Pursuit for perfection
Considering what my desktop can do, how do I use and how big my laptop can be here is a list of requirements I've came up with:
- Intel i7 quad-core > 2Ghz
- at least 8GB RAM
- at least 256G SSD drive.
- Size 14”-15” (13" considered)
- Integrated + discreet GPU (Nvidia optimus technology welcome)
- Screen with resolution 1920x1080
- Ability to drive 3 external screens when docked or via built in ports: thunderbolt/hdmi/display port (i.e. not usb 3, preferable not via vga or some crazy adapters)
- Back-lit keyboard
- Weight up to 3.5kg
- Thickness up to 2.5cm
- At least 5 hours battery for lightweight use (text editing/coding/browsing)
It seems that Apple's Mac Book Pro is pretty much the only laptop that meets all expectations above. Furthermore it comes with thunderbolt ports, these little sockets offer 10Gbit/s access straight to your motherboard meaning all of a sudden an external GPU is possible! Here is a list of 'second-choice' laptops:
- Asus U500vz - sweet but will never run 3 screens due to lack of outputs, keyboard has extra keys above arrows
- Dell Precision 15" - sweet but big & clunky
- Dell XPS 15 - 2 weeks waiting time, for some reasons version with SSD disk disappeared from the website at the time of writing
- Sony Vaio Z - 1 month waiting time, requires docking station for discrete gpu, prohibitevly expensive (£2500!)
- Sony Vaio S - 1 month waiting time, will never run 3 screens due to lack of outputs
- Samsung 9 series 15" - i5 and small SSD
2 weeks with Mac Book Pro Retina
I've got the 512 SSD, 2.6Ghz Macbook with Retina Screen which I've configured to triple boot:
Number Start End Size File system Name Flags 1 20.5kB 210MB 210MB fat32 EFI system partition boot 2 210MB 75.2GB 75.0GB hfs+ Customer 3 75.2GB 75.9GB 650MB hfs+ Recovery HD 4 75.9GB 76.0GB 105MB hfs+ efi-grub 5 76.0GB 76.1GB 105MB ext2 boot 6 76.1GB 345GB 268GB ext4 arch 7 345GB 345GB 134MB Microsoft reserved partition msftres 8 345GB 500GB 156GB ntfs Basic data partition
where partitions 1-3 are what laptop came with (just shrinked), 4 is for Refind, 5-6 for Arch Linux and 7-8 for Win 8.
Installing system is relatively easy - you can boot an EFI capable boot loader or kernel either from USB or using an SD card. Partitions can be resized from OS X and formatted using Linux installer/livecd. Remember to boot with Thunderport plugged in. After installing Linux I've also managed to install windows 8 using EFI boot without much problem.
However straight after installation I've run into problems: wifi connection was really bad and every other reboot I would encounter weird problem: screen would go black or laptop would not fully come out from suspend. I've spent long days trying to resolve these issues, some of my findings:
- You can switch to intel GPU from OS X and the setting will persist across reboots. To do this you need to run little tool called gfxCardStatus (version 2.2.1 - important), set it to 'integrated only' and then boot into Linux. For some reasons version 2.3 doesn't do the trick, so you need 2.2.1. Afterwards you can switch off Nvidia card using vgaswitcheroo and enjoy the 7 hours long battery live.
- Other folks have been trying to run Linux on these machines as well, here are some materials online I've found useful:
- Wiki article about installing and running Arch on Macbook Retina
- Threads on Ubuntu Forum: disabling nvidia and MBPr in general
- How to reset NVRAM
- Guide how to disable built-in GPUs and switch gpu connected to the screen from withing EFI shell - interesting but in the end wasn't useful for me.
- HiDPI theme for Sublime based on Soda; and a bug that is making things harder.
- Powertop is a great piece of software to identify power-saving optimisations. You can export 'tunables' and automate enabling additional hardware power-saving features.
- lightum will let you configure your Linux to adapt keyboard backlight to the environment
Screen is wonderful. On Linux with DPI set to 144 and running Firefox with layout.css.devPixelsPerPx set to 1.5 web is beatiful. Fonts are crisps and sharp and you're still getting an equivalent of roughly 1920x1080 worth of space. Windows 8 with 'zoom' set to 150% looks great as well in apps that support this setting.
MBPr is a really powerful laptop. It can easily drive 4 screens using Discrete NVIDIA GPU (2 through mini display ports, 1 via hdmi and the built-in Retina screen). However if mobility is what you're after, switch off Discrete GPU and you're looking at 6-7 hours worth of battery when doing light work. Powertop reports 14-15W discharge while doing normal 'coding' + browsing, playing something on Youtube will raise this figure to 20-odd Watts.
Sound is surprisingly good for a laptop but if silence is what you're after - as long as you stick with the integrated graphics and don't do much compiling (or anything else cpu-intensive) you're very unlikely to hear fans at all!
Not all Linux apps are high-DPI compatible. Here are some examples: Firefox is brilliant, Chrome not really. KDE will work with some tweaks but Sublime Text has some problems that cannot be fixed with themes. On the screenshot below you will notice that while setting default zoom level to 150% partially resolves the issue with Chrome, the interface of the browser itself (historically referred to as chrome) is very small and makes using chrome uncomfortable:
There is no ethernet port and wireless needs firmware extracted from proprietary drivers. Thunderbolt-to-ethernet port comes handy but there is no support for hot-plugging it in Linux.
If you want to plug in external monitors, you will probably need to grab a DP adapter though it's not too bad as mini-dp is now becoming a standard thus adapters are plentiful.
15" Macbook Pro Retina comes with 2 GPUs however Apple decided to use a digital multiplexer to switch between cards connected to the retina screen rather than to use the hybrid approach such as using Nvidia's Optimus technolgy. It works ok for OS X though I did manage to boot into Macbook's operating system and have only external screen working. However support on Linux (or Windows 8 as for this matter) is virtually non-existent. This was the main deal breaker for me.
Wifi support under Linux is really poor. Broadcom's chipset is only partially supported. As long as you stick with 802.11g standard routers you should be ok, with kernel 3.8 I've experienced occasional connection breaks and a throughput of about 1MB/s. It gets worse when you connect to the 802.11n standard router - at the moment there is no support for it at all in the driver so you would be capped at theoretical speed 54Mbit/s, and I've experience much worse connection drops when connected to the 'n' standard router. An alternative is to try the ndis_wrapper but others tried this and it doesn't seem to be any better. Second deal breaker.
If you're happy to use OS X, this is a great piece of hardware and probably worth it's orbital price. Unfortunately Apple's peculiar choice of hardware means that. at least as of February 2013. you won't be able to run Linux or Windows 8 on it (Windows 7 through fake Bios and 'Bootcamp' should work). Luckily Apple let's you return a laptop within 14 calendar days and that's exactly what I've done. Nevertheless this has been the closest I've seen to a worthy desktop replacement so one that works for me must be coming very soon!